These Thanksgiving Episodes of ‘Friends’ are Surprisingly Dark
While the holiday episodes of Friends are some of the most memorable of the show’s career — the darker implications behind plots are easily forgotten amongst the laughter. The show’s holiday installments have a way of highlighting characters’ quirks and backstories, often revealing more than just funny one-liners. This intertwinement of humor and the morose is executed so well that it’s easy for the more somber themes to fly under the radar.
In anticipation of the upcoming holiday, let’s look back on some of the darker themes that pop up in those classic episodes:
5x8: ‘The One With All the Thanksgivings’
This one is jam-packed. Known for its humor and iconic flashbacks, this episode explores darker themes that delve into the characters’ insecurities and emotional scars — and we’re not just talking about the hair. In a flashback to the early 80s — Rachel and Monica are seniors in high school, while Ross and Chandler are nearing the end of college. While each of the characters has memorable distressing roots exposed in this episode, most notably are those of Monica and Chandler.
Chandler and his negative relationship with Thanksgiving is well-known. But underneath all the jokes lies the answer to his emotional barriers throughout the seasons. Famously, Chandler learned that his parents were getting a divorce halfway through Thanksgiving dinner. His parents’ infidelities, cynicism, and jokey-ness around their marital issues infused similar coping mechanisms in Chandler. He uses humor to deal with tough topics and feelings, and this is ever present in the Thanksgiving episodes — where family trauma, grudges, and conflicts are at the forefront. This desire to push down emotion makes him vulnerable to not just hurting himself, but hurting others, like Monica.
In flashbacks to the early 80s, whilst Chandler and Ross are washing dishes, Chandler insults Monica’s weight — without knowing that she is right behind him. This is shown to be a pivotal moment in her life, having already struggled with body image issues for years up to that point. The emotional impact this has on Monica fuels her obsession with weight loss and perfectionism, something that accompanies her for the majority of the show.
Monica, already desperately seeking validation, especially from her parents and her older brother’s cool college friend, Chandler, is desperate to transform in the attempt to prove Chandler wrong. When she does lose weight and completely alter her appearance, her plan to attempt to seduce Chandler goes horribly wrong — accidentally severing part of his toe with a kitchen knife in the process.
Both Chandler and Monica’s main personality quirks, self-deprecating humor and perfectionism, are highlighted in this episode. What is often seen as a personality trait, and a funny narrative throughout various episodes, are serious, unresolved insecurities.
3x9: ‘The One With the Football’
This episode is rife with sibling rivalry, exclusion, and the pursuit of validation. Unlike other episodes, the darkness of this plot becomes evident from the start. The pursuit of “The Geller Cup” starts as a fun holiday pastime, but soon turns into a serious competition rooted in unresolved childhood issues.
Reigniting their childhood rivalry through a football game, Monica and Ross out themselves as serious rivals through their behavior, as the rest of the gang is left helplessly to watch. Intense jealousy, tension, and the need for parental approval showcase the two siblings’ lack of healthy conflict resolution skills in their upbringing.
Monica’s feelings of being overshadowed by her brother, along with Ross’s desire to assert dominance and remain seen as “the golden child” highlight the pressures associated with status within their family. The two’s inability to let go of past grievances makes the game almost unbearable for everyone else trying to play. Especially Rachel and Phoebe, who struggle to be taken seriously in the game — which speaks to a deeper issue within the group.
Underestimated, ignored, and excluded — Rachel and Phoebe struggle to be taken seriously within the football game. What can easily be excused as a funny joke, not wanting the bad players on your team, speaks to a larger issue that affects the two characters on a seasonal basis. Phoebe’s quirky personality often leads others in the group to ignore her, not taking what she has to say seriously. Rachel, a girly-girl, attempts to engage herself and contribute to the game, but the team’s internal assumptions lead them to exclude her in huddles, and never pass her the ball. Neither is valued, and this subtle dynamic mirrors real-life scenarios — as they are often marginalized within their social group, even unintentionally. The darker themes of rivalry, exclusion, and the need for validation run beneath the surface of this layered and relatable Thanksgiving story.
1x9: ‘The One Where the Underdog Gets Away’
When the Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade Underdog balloon gets loose, it symbolizes more than a fun mishap. It becomes a shared moment for the group, as they all feel like an “underdog” in some aspect of their life — whether it’s career struggles, family disappointment, or romantic heartaches. The chaotic mishaps of their lives are often used for comedic purposes, but they also reflect broader issues. So when everyone gets locked out of Monica’s apartment while Thanksgiving dinner is on the stove — the situation calls for more than just laughs.
All six characters are spending Thanksgiving away from their families for various reasons. While Joey, Rachel, and Chandler simply have no other exciting invitations — Ross, Monica, and Phoebe’s reasons for staying away subtly highlight strained family relationships. Ross is having difficulty accepting the fact that his ex-wife is having a child with a new partner. The vulnerability and pain he undergoes over the heartbreak of his divorce, and the thought of having a limited role in his soon-to-be son’s life is shown, but not expressed to its full extent.
The same is true of Phoebe’s sense of displacement. When her grandmother’s boyfriend unexpectedly comes back, Phoebe is left to look for new plans — as the two had originally planned to spend the holiday together. This impacts Phoebe more than one would notice if you don’t know her family backstory. Her mother committed suicide when she was a child, her father left the family, and her sister and she have a very distant, strained relationship. Phoebe spent a large part of her early life living on the streets, therefore, her unstable and unconventional family life is a common comedic theme — and we only ever skim the surface of the negative impact this has on her.
At the forefront of this episode is Monica’s overbearing desire to create a perfect Thanksgiving meal. This is exacerbated when everyone gets locked out of the apartment with the turkey in the oven, and we see the full extent of Monica’s need for control and desire to prove herself. The dark themes are understated but present, particularly when you look beyond the surface humor.
8x9: ‘The One With the Rumor’
Bullying, body shaming, insecurity, and the lasting impact of high school trauma. Brad Pitt isn’t the only shocking thing about this episode. This episode centers mostly around Rachel — the character who would probably win the “most improved” award if it came down to it. She goes through a dramatic change throughout the show–leaving her fiancé at the altar, cutting all her credit cards in half, and learning how to support herself for the first time in her life. But the repercussions of her past behavior come back in this episode when Will (played by Pitt), a former high school classmate, joins the gang for Thanksgiving dinner, and brings with him years of festering hatred for Rachel.
Rachel’s past as a “mean girl” is revisited, with Will accusing her of mocking him and others for their weight or social status. The revelation that Ross and Will co-founded the “I Hate Rachel” Club in high school highlights the cruelty of adolescent cliques and the lasting impact of bullying. The club’s actions — including spreading a false and damaging rumor about Rachel — reflect the darker aspects of social ostracism and how spiteful behavior can leave emotional scars, even if those involved later regret it. Ross’s admission of his role in the “I Hate Rachel” Club is a betrayal that deeply hurts Rachel — which adds a layer of emotional complexity to their relationship.
The episode touches on the long-term emotional impact of body image issues and how societal pressure to conform to certain standards can lead to deep-seated resentment. It represents the feelings that often can arise around the holidays — as we are brought together with both those we have known all our lives and new friendships.
. . .
Whatever your holiday plans may be, take a moment to seek out the light in the darkness — just as these episodes of Friends do. Embrace the laughter, let go of old grievances, and remind yourself that comedy is simply tragedy plus time. What feels like sadness today might one day become a story worth smiling about.
